Telluride · Colorado

New Sheridan Hotel

Name: New Sheridan Hotel
Address: 231 W. Colorado Ave., Telluride, Colorado, 81435, US
Rating: 9.2

231 W. Colorado Ave., Telluride, Colorado, 81435

The experience

Historic Downtown Hotel in Telluride, Colorado

Luxurious Amenities: Enjoy rooms with modern conveniences like a flat-screen TV, iPod docking station, and laptop safe. Take advantage of the rooftop bar with stunning mountain views, spa services, and a helpful concierge.

Delicious Dining Options: Indulge in mouthwatering steak and seafood at the on-site New Sheridan Chop House. Sip on cocktails at the full-service bar for a complete dining experience.

Convenient Location: Just 2 blocks from Telluride Ski Resort, and close to attractions like the New Sheridan Opera House and Bridal Veil Falls. Free Wi-Fi and all-day coffee in the lobby make your stay even more enjoyable.

Book now to experience a blend of history and luxury at the New Sheridan Hotel in Telluride!

At the hotel

Popular amenities

37 listed

24-hour front desk
Bar
Cashless payment available
Cleaning standards that are effective against Coronavirus
Concierge service
Face masks for guests available
Facilities for disabled guests
Fax/photocopying
First aid kit available
Food delivered to guest room

View all amenities

Free Parking
Golf course
Guest rooms disinfected between stays
Guests can opt-out any cleaning services during stay
Hand sanitizer in guest room and key areas
Heating
Laundry washed per local authority guidelines
Lift / Elevator
Non-smoking rooms
Non-smoking throughout
Parking
Physical distancing in dining areas
Physical distancing rules followed
Restaurant
Room service
Safety deposit box
Sanitized tableware & silverware
Screens / Barriers between staff and guests for safety
Shared stationery like menus, pens are removed
Ski pass vendor
Ski school
Ski storage
Skiing
Staff adhere to local safety protocols
Street parking
Thermometers for guests provided by property
WiFi available

Live guest feedback

Guest reviews

9.2out of 10

Premium Price, Budget Experience
tippy799 · Friends getaway · 2026-07-22
4/10
“I was aware we were staying in a historic property, but I've never paid so much money to receive so little. A few things that I was surprised / disappointed by: - Parking. Understand that you will haul your bags up and down a hill to park on a street behind the hotel. I understand the space limitations but incredibly inconvenient. - No air conditioning. While it is not typically needed in Telluride we visited in July and it was very difficult to sleep as the room was very warm. When you open the window (as suggested by a sign in the room) it's then noisy and if you're really lucky the smell of someone's marijuana on the street drifts up into your room. - No breakfast available, only coffee. - The room was clean, but with the small space there was nowhere to sit and relax but the actual bed. Made getting some work done on my laptop pretty difficult. - I suppose you can understand each of these issues with a historic property, but the biggest disappointment was the staff and service. Each person we interacted with seemed to be more dismissive of our needs than the one before. So while I understand that a historic property can't offer all of the amenities of a modern hotel you would at least think the service would be commiserate with the amount paid.”
Friendly staff and great amenities
jangV499EX · Family · 2026-07-19
10/10
“We were warmly greeted by every staff member we encountered. Our favorite was Steve Foster - the bartender at the Chop House and Wine Bar. He remembered our names and where we hailed from. The room was cozy and the amenities were more than adequate.”
Thank you and great stay
tracioliver · Friends getaway · 2026-03-15
10/10
“Arrived in town with a reservation at another hotel that I never confirmed... Started driving threw town and asking for a room. The Sheridan was our 3rd attempt and they had 1 room left, we were willing to pay most anything and the Sheridan not only offered us their last room, they gave us a discount as the last room backed up to the Opera that had a show that night until 11PM. Great room and when we asked for another hour to stay to noon the next day and take a hike they agreed to that as well. Great coffee, very accomodating staff, specifically Carl/Karl. Thank you and we will be back.”
Downhill (pun intended)
Q5210CDcharlieh · Friends getaway · 2026-03-02
6/10
“Great hotel with an amazing provenance but very downhill compared to previous years. The staff is great and they have a winning attitude but the details disappoint this year. "Breakfast" is now served from 10:00 am to 12:00 pm (terrible for skiers), a change from previous years. When we asked why we were told they had to lay off a lot of staff because of the tough ski season. Coffee one morning was not available because the hotel had "run out of filters". We were told they would buy some as soon as a local store opened where they could buy more. This seems like an issue management could have anticipated. The owner/manager seemed to always have a scowl on his face.. We were staying at the hotel and also ate two dinners there (one was $750 for the three of us) and he never approached us to engage and speak with us or check in on us despite being always close by. He seemed more concerned with arranging chairs than engaging with his guests. I worked for many years in hospitality in NYC at top restaurants and I know when management is disengaged and the staff has to overcompensate. Service was friendly and warm but lots of kitchen errors (we were served another table's entrees as soon as we sat down one evening, and then one of us received his salad while the rest of us waited for the other appetizers to arrive. They didn't until we called attention to it and then we were served the wrong appetizers, which they corrected, but it was a bit of a comedy of errors from the kitchen). Again, the servers are excellent but it seems management/ownership has checked out. I know it was a tough year for Telluride but that is no excuse for the absence of graciousness. Hospitality is a verb as well as a noun, and ownership seems to have forgotten that. Sad to say this year it was hard to justify the expense of staying there.”

Our insider’s guide to Telluride

Where to stay in Telluride

Hotel info and reviews come from third-party sources.